Divorce is a challenging and emotional process, there’s no way around it. Throwing a shared home into the mix only increases the stress. We’ll walk you through the key aspects of navigating the chaos and help you make informed decisions to move forward effectively. I also want to preface this by saying I’m not a lawyer and this is not legal advice!

Legal Considerations

Before putting your house on the market, determine who has ownership rights to the property. This may be straightforward if the house was jointly bought and owned, but it becomes more complicated if one party owned it before the marriage or if it was inherited.

Texas (where we’re located) is a community property state. Generally, that means that if you didn’t intentionally set up a way to keep ownership of a property separate, both spouses are entitled to their share of the home value. This depends on your state jurisdictions, so be sure to consult an attorney for exact answers.

In many jurisdictions, once divorce papers are filed, neither party can sell major assets without court approval or the other spouse's consent. Whatever you do, make sure you have a clear agreement between both parties regarding the sale that’s documented and approved by your respective attorneys.

Financial Implications

The financial aspects of selling a house during divorce can also be complex. You'll need to agree on how to divide the proceeds from the sale. This division may not always be a simple 50/50 split, especially if one party made larger contributions to the purchase or maintenance of the property.

Depending on how long you've owned the home and the amount of profit, you may be subject to capital gains tax. I also recommend consulting with a local specialist if you need assistance or recommendations in this area.

Perhaps most importantly, if there's an existing mortgage on the property, you'll need to decide how to handle it. This often involves selling the property and paying it off with the sale proceeds. Let me be clear, if the original mortgage is in both parties’ names (a joint mortgage), it will be very difficult to keep it. Whoever keeps the property will likely be forced to refinance, which means saying goodbye to your sweet 3% mortgage rate.

Should I Sell Before or After the Divorce?

A common question couples face when dealing with property during a divorce is whether to sell the house before or after finalizing the divorce. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but here are some factors to consider:

Selling Before Divorce

1. Simplifies asset division: Since you’ve already sold, you already know the fair market value of the home. No drawn-out negotiations about what the property is worth!
2. Provides closure: Offers a cleaner break and a sense of closure that allows both parties to move on more quickly. You can also use the sale proceeds to look for your next living option.
3. Reduces ongoing expenses: If neither party can afford the home individually, selling sooner rather than later can prevent the accumulation of additional mortgage payments, property taxes, and maintenance costs.

Selling After Divorce

1. More time for preparation: Give you more time to prepare the house for sale and make improvements/repairs, increasing its sale value.
2. Clearer ownership: Once the divorce is final, ownership of the house is established, which simplifies the selling process as there are no joint decisions on price.
3. Less emotional stress: Dealing with the house sale separately from the divorce reduces the emotional burden during an already stressful time.
4. Potential tax benefits: Waiting to sell can offer tax advantages, for example, if one spouse has been living in the home as a primary residence.

Factors to Consider

When deciding whether to sell before or after divorce, consider:

1. Financial needs: Do either of you need the proceeds from the sale to secure new housing?
2. Ability to cooperate: Can you realistically work together effectively to manage the sale process?
3. Market conditions: What does the real estate market look like now, and what are the projections?
4. Tax implications: Consult with a tax professional to understand how timing might affect your tax obligations.
5. Emotional readiness: Are both parties emotionally prepared to sell the home?
6. Legal advice: What do your respective divorce attorneys recommend based on your specific situation?

While the timing and circumstances of the sale are important, the most important factor is usually that both parties can agree on a course of action. A mutual decision, even if it's not the ideal one, leads to a smoother process overall.

Do I Have to Sell My House in a Divorce?

Another common question is whether you must sell a home in a divorce. The short answer is no, so long as the alternative options are viable and fit the situation at hand.

Alternatives to Selling

1. Buyout: One spouse can buy out the other's share of the equity. This allows one party to keep the house while providing the other with their fair share of the asset.
2. Deferred sale: Both parties can agree to postpone the sale, often until children reach a certain age or milestone (like graduating high school). This is sometimes called a "nesting" arrangement.
3. refinancing: The spouse keeping the house may need to refinance the mortgage to remove the other spouse's name and potentially cash out some equity to pay the departing spouse. As mentioned above, if the mortgage is jointly owned, the bank will likely not allow you to keep it.
4. Continued co-ownership: In some cases, ex-spouses continue to co-own the property, either as an investment or to provide stability for children. Realistically, I don’t recommend this option unless you have no choice or you’re sure it’s a good idea.

Factors to Consider

1. Financial ability: Can either spouse afford to keep the house on their own, including mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, and maintenance?
2. Emotional attachment: Is there a strong emotional reason for one party to keep the home, such as minimizing disruption for children?
3. Other assets: Are there enough other assets to offset the value of the house in the overall property division?
4. Agreement between parties: Can you and your spouse agree on who keeps the house or how to handle it?
5. Court orders: In contentious divorces, a judge may order the sale of the house as part of the property division, so keep this in mind as well.
6. Legal considerations: How does your state law mandate property must be split in a divorce? Are there any other agreements that predated the marriage to consider?
7. Tax implications: How will capital gains taxes be handled?

The decision about what to do with the house in a divorce should be part of your overall strategy for dividing assets and moving forward. While it's a scary decision, you still must consider it in the context of your entire financial picture and future goals.

Joint Decision Making is Hard

I want to bring special attention in this section to just how many decisions must be made (and therefore shared) in this process. Keep this in mind as you move forward.

Firstly, there’s timing. Consider current market conditions - is it a buyer's market or a seller's market? How quickly can the house sell and what price can you can expect to receive? If both parties aren’t emotionally prepared for the sale, it can throw a wrench in decision-making and lead to conflicts.

You’ll need to consider house preparation. Divorcing couples need to reach an agreement on which repairs or upgrades are necessary to make the home marketable. This might include minor touch-ups or major renovations (and the costs that those entail), depending on the property's condition and market norms. If you have an ugly house, this can be overwhelming. Don’t forget staging, too!

There’s also the real estate agent. The agent should act as a neutral third party, representing the interests of both spouses equally, which is easier said than done. They need excellent communication skills to manage interactions between divorcing spouses, their attorneys, and potential buyers.

Then there’s the price. You'll have to balance the desire for a quick sale against maximizing profit. Sometimes, a faster sale at a slightly lower price might be preferable to a long, drawn-out process that delays the divorce proceedings.

Showings and open houses can be especially challenging during a divorce if one spouse still lives in the home. As hard as it is, try to establish clear guidelines for scheduling viewings that respect both parties' privacy and daily routines.

If this process hasn’t been stressful already, it probably will when you start getting offers. Have a clear process for reviewing and responding to them as evenly and jointly as possible. If you can't agree, consider having your respective attorneys or a mediator involved in the decision-making process. Disputes in negotiations like this can escalate, so beware!

Finally, once you’ve accepted an offer, you’re over the hump. Most of the leg work is done and all that’s left is to close on the sale. Your attorneys and agent will cover most of the process from here. Just hope the buyers don’t back out!

If it’s not already clear, selling a house is stressful. In the context of a divorce, this process is even worse! If you’re in the Austin or Central Texas area and looking to sell ASAP and move on, we can help. We specialize in fast, fair, cash offers and can close in as little as 7 days. Reach out today!

Concluding Thoughts

Selling a house during a divorce is rarely easy, but sometimes it’s the only choice you have. I hope that the information above will help you navigate this challenging situation effectively.

Above all, try to maintain open communication with your spouse and focus on your shared goals regarding the house. Conflicts are difficult to set aside, but a cooperative approach will lead to a smoother transition to the next chapter of your lives.

‍